U.S. Credit and Labor Markets Cool in Tandem as Policy Restraint Takes Hold
The expanded text is shown below.
Recent U.S. economic data point to an economy that is slowing in a measured and increasingly synchronized manner across household credit conditions and labor market dynamics. The latest readings on consumer credit, employment, and job openings suggest that restrictive monetary policy is continuing to dampen demand while avoiding the abrupt dislocations typically associated with late-cycle downturns. Rather than signaling distress, the data indicate normalization after several years of unusually strong credit growth and labor tightness. Consumer credit outstanding expanded modestly in December, reflecting a continued deceleration in household borrowing. Total consumer credit rose by approximately $9.2 billion, well below the average monthly increases observed earlier in the expansion. Revolving credit, which largely reflects credit card borrowing, increased at a slower pace, while nonrevolving credit—primarily auto and student loans— showed more subdued growth. This moderation suggests that households are becoming more cautious in their use of credit as interest rates remain elevated and lending standards tighter than in previous years. The slowdown in revolving credit is particularly notable.
After years of strong growth fueled by post pandemic consumption and rising prices, credit card balances are now expanding at a more restrained rate. Higher borrowing costs appear to be exerting a meaningful influence on consumer behavior, encouraging more selective spending and balance management. At the same time, delinquency rates remain contained, indicating that households are adjusting without widespread financial stress. This combination points to a cooling phase rather than a deterioration in consumer credit quality.
Labor market data for December reinforce this picture of gradual adjustment. Nonfarm payroll employment continued to grow, but at a slower pace than earlier in the year. The economy added approximately 155,000 jobs, down from monthly averages that consistently exceeded 200,000 during periods of stronger momentum. Employment gains remained concentrated in services, particularly health care and professional services, while more cyclical sectors such as manufacturing showed limited growth. The unemployment rate edged higher to 4.1 percent, up from 4.0 percent in the prior month. While the increase was modest, it marks a continued drift away from the historically tight conditions that prevailed in the immediate post-pandemic period. Importantly, the rise in unemployment reflects slower hiring rather than a surge in layoffs. Initial and continuing claims data remain relatively stable, suggesting that firms are reducing labor demand gradually rather than aggressively cutting payrolls.
Wage growth also continued to ease. Average hourly earnings rose 0.3 percent month over month, bringing the year-over-year increase to 3.9 percent, down from levels above 4.5 percent earlier in the cycle. This moderation in wage pressures is significant for inflation dynamics, particularly in labor-intensive service sectors. Slower wage growth supports the broader disinflation process without undermining household income growth outright. Further insight into labor market cooling comes from the Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey. Job openings declined to 8.8 million, down from 9.1 million in the previous reading. While still elevated by historical standards, openings have fallen substantially from their peak above 12 million in 2022. The decline reflects reduced hiring intentions rather than a collapse in labor demand, consistent with firms adjusting to higher financing costs and more uncertain growth prospects. The ratio of job openings to unemployed workers continued to normalize, moving closer to pre-pandemic levels. This shift suggests a gradual rebalancing of labor supply and demand, easing upward pressure on wages without generating widespread job losses. Quits—a key indicator of worker confidence—remained stable at 2.2 percent, indicating that employees are less inclined to switch jobs than during the peak of labor market tightness but are not signaling distress or fear of unemployment.
Hiring rates also softened slightly, reinforcing the view that firms are becoming more selective. At the same time, layoff rates remained low, underscoring the absence of acute stress in labor markets. Employers appear focused on managing headcount through attrition and slower recruitment rather than aggressive workforce reductions.
Taken together, the consumer credit and labor market data suggest a coherent macroeconomic narrative. Higher interest rates are working through the economy as intended, restraining borrowing, cooling hiring, and easing wage growth. However, the adjustment remains orderly. Households continue to service debt, workers continue to find jobs, and firms retain sufficient confidence to avoid sharp cutbacks. U.S. Credit and Labor Markets Cool in Tandem as Policy Restraint Takes Hold Source: The Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Federal Reserve For financial markets, the message is nuanced. The economy is no longer operating at the pace seen in the immediate post-pandemic rebound, but neither is it approaching recessionary conditions. Slower credit growth and softer hiring suggest reduced upside risks to inflation, while stable employment and contained delinquencies limit downside risks to growth. This balance supports expectations for a prolonged period of restrictive but stable monetary policy. Looking ahead, the sustainability of this softening trajectory will depend on how households and firms respond to persistently high borrowing costs.
Continued moderation in job openings and wage growth would reinforce disinflation trends, while renewed acceleration in credit usage or hiring could complicate the outlook. External factors, including global growth conditions and energy prices, also remain important variables. In sum, the December data on consumer credit, employment, and labor turnover point to an economy that is cooling in a controlled and broadly healthy manner. Credit demand is slowing, labor markets are normalizing, and wage pressures are easing without triggering widespread stress. While risks remain, the latest indicators suggest that the transition away from an overheated post-pandemic economy is unfolding with greater stability than many had feared. From a policy perspective, these developments support a cautious Federal Reserve stance. The moderation in credit growth reduces concerns about excess demand, while easing labor market pressures strengthen confidence that inflation can continue to drift lower. At the same time, the absence of sharp weakness argues against rapid policy easing. Policymakers are likely to interpret the data as validation of a strategy that prioritizes patience and data dependence.
Economic Calendar This week features a broad mix of inflation, housing, trade, and activity data that will help investors assess the strength of the U.S. economy as the year progresses and refine expectations for monetary policy. With several high-impact releases clustered midweek, markets will be particularly sensitive to signals on price pressures and consumer demand. On Monday, attention turns to the 10-Year Note Auction, an important event for fixed-income markets. Demand at this auction provides insight into investor appetite for long-term U.S. government debt and can influence Treasury yields and borrowing costs. On Tuesday, inflation and housing data for December take center stage. The Core CPI and headline CPI readings will offer a critical update on underlying and overall inflation trends, both of which are closely monitored by the Federal Reserve. These figures can have an immediate impact on interest rate expectations, equity valuations, and currency markets. Also on Tuesday, New Home Sales for October will shed light on demand conditions in the housing market, particularly how higher interest rates are affecting buyer activity. The Federal Budget Balance will also be released, providing insight into government spending and revenue dynamics, which can influence Treasury issuance expectations and longer-term fiscal considerations. On Wednesday, producer-level inflation and external balance data will be in focus. Core PPI and headline PPI will help assess cost pressures faced by producers and provide an early indication of future consumer inflation trends. The Current Account balance for the third quarter will offer a snapshot of trade flows and income transfers with the rest of the world, an important indicator for understanding external financing needs and capital movements. Retail Sales and Core Retail Sales for November will be especially important for gauging the strength of consumer spending, which remains a key driver of U.S. economic growth. Strong or weak readings here can significantly affect growth expectations and market sentiment. On Thursday, Existing Home Sales for December will provide further insight into housing market conditions, including the pace of transactions and the impact of financing costs on activity. The TIC Net Long-Term Transactions report will also be released, offering details on foreign purchases of U.S. long-term securities, a key indicator of international capital flows and demand for U.S. assets. On Friday, the week concludes with Industrial Production for December, which measures output across manufacturing, mining, and utilities. This report helps assess the momentum of the industrial sector and overall economic activity, and it can influence expectations for GDP growth in the current quarter. Overall, this week’s data will play a crucial role in shaping market expectations around inflation trends, consumer resilience, and economic momentum. Softer inflation readings combined with steady consumer activity could support risk assets and reinforce expectations for a more accommodative policy path. Conversely, upside surprises in prices or signs of weakening demand could increase volatility across equities, bonds, and currencies as investors reassess the outlook for growth and interest rates.
Technical Terms
1.A revolver is a borrower, either individual or corporate, who maintains a balance on a revolving credit line and makes monthly payments while accessing funds as needed. 2.Revolving credit refers to a type of credit account that allows the borrower to repeatedly borrow up to a certain limit. Making payments reduces the balance owed and frees up credit, which can be used again. Credit cards, personal lines of credit, and home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) are all types of revolving credit. 3.A utilization fee is a periodic fee that some lenders charge borrowers whose outstanding balances exceed a certain percentage of their available credit. Utilization fees are most common on revolving lines of credit and term loans for businesses. 4.JOLTS is a monthly survey by the Bureau of Labor Statistics measuring U.S. job vacancies, hires, and separations. It provides insights into labor demand and workforce turnover, aiding understanding of the labor market. Job openings include part-time and temporary positions that are expected to start within 30 days. 5.Delinquency in finance occurs when a borrower fails to make timely payments on debt obligations like loans or credit cards. Missed payments can lead to delinquency, which in turn negatively impacts a person’s credit score and can lead to default. Delinquency is not just limited to borrowers; financial professionals can also be considered delinquent if they neglect their fiduciary duties
